SARTOR WANTS 'RELEVANT' NATIONAL PARKS
By Peter Prineas
NSW Environment Minister Frank Sartor introduced his controversial national parks 'visitors and tourists' bill into State Parliament in June, saying the legislation was needed to keep national parks 'relevant'.
The Minister said the bill 'clarified' the existing legislation but this rang a little hollow when he mentioned three separate legal opinions explaining its effects. These legal advices were contradicted by yet another obtained by environmental groups concerned that the bill would open the floodgates to tourism developments in parks. One thing is clear: the legislation will produce more litigation.
Mr Sartor quoted a legal advice saying the bill would 'not broaden in any significant way the range of purposes for which leases and licences may be granted in national parks'. Yet the bill introduced a range of uses for new developments in parks that were formerly limited to existing buildings and structures. These uses include research facilities, conference and function centres, recreational, educational and cultural activities, sporting activities and retail shops. Permitting new developments for these purposes is a significant change.
The bill also opens up wilderness areas to commercial operations – where they were formerly prohibited - and allows existing buildings and modified areas within national parks to be leased or licensed for ''any use'. The Department of Environment has surveyed the parks for modified areas and they are said to total thousands of hectares.
Mr Sartor’s draft bill was revised in negotiations with environment groups and some checks and balances were inserted, however they are weak compared with the enhanced decision-making power and discretion conferred on the Minister.
In the Lower House, independent MP Clover Moore opposed the bill and asked that 'this complex environmental legislation' lie upon the table so concerns about it could be resolved. But by the end of following day the Government had pushed the bill through both Houses.
The Coalition parties did not oppose the bill and failed to gain support for an essentially cosmetic amendment that would have prevented it from affecting national parks in World Heritage Areas.
In the Upper House, Ian Cohen for the Greens opposed the Bill and moved a series of amendments unsuccessfully. He read into the record a legal advice from Tim Robertson SC which in summary said that while the legislation had been improved in some respects, there was a need for further safeguards.
During the debate, the very extensive visitor developments at Kosciuszko National Park received little attention. Kosciuszko’s developments tend to be set aside either as an historical legacy, or as a special case because of the snowfields. The legacy argument is unconvincing when it is considered that a major new development at Kosciusko’s Perisher Valley was approved as recently as 2006. The Planning Minister at the time, Frank Sartor, announced that the Perisher car park, an area equal to five football fields, would be the site for seven four-storey buildings forming a village centre, with 239 apartments and associated retail, commercial and recreational facilities. This development is yet to proceed, but if there are any barriers to it in the National Parks and Wildlife Act, presumably they will be removed when Mr Sartor’s amendments take effect.
Kosciuszko rates as a special case mainly because of its different culture. There is a long established demand for facilities in that Park and an expectation that they will be provided. If even a fraction of this demand is shown for tourist resorts in other national parks, Minister Sartor’s new legislation does much to create expectations that they be provided.
The tourism industry’s push into NSW national parks was always a serious threat and in its initial form Sartor’s draft bill proposed the greatest change to the National Parks and Wildlife Act since its inception. Barrister Tim Robertson described it as 'revolutionary'. Yet the environment groups ran a weak campaign. Two public meetings attended by this writer were remarkable for a parade of environment group logos and an absence of most of the leadership. It was left mainly to Greens MP Ian Cohen and academic Ralph Buckley to make the case.
Arguably the battle was lost some years ago when the ACF and the IUCN signed up to a Tourism and Transport Forum (TTF) manifesto called 'National Parks & Tourism: A Natural Partnership'. It may have seemed like a good idea at the time, but it has helped the TTF – a well-oiled tourism industry lobby – to move national parks policy and management to a stance that is now much more accepting of development.
The TTF has worked its way around Australia's national parks agencies, with New South Wales as the last stop. The public campaign began here when the State Government commissioned the O'Neill report, essentially a spray against restrictions and regulations in national parks. This was followed by a Government Taskforce on Tourism and National Parks that stymied environment groups by taking on board a couple of their senior people. The Government also dispensed funds to key groups – $20,000 each to the National Parks Association and the Nature Conservation Council – to keep them busy writing submissions. The Taskforce report appeared late in 2008 and called for the concessions and leasing provisions in the National Parks and Wildlife Act to be “clarified”. The report was quickly accepted by Premier Nathan Rees. The legislation that passed though the NSW Parliament last month is the end result of this process.
The concerned public faces a long struggle to regain lost ground. Nothing dramatic is likely to happen in the lead up to a State election in March 2011 and it is noticeable that in his recent statements the Environment Minister has sought to play down the effects of the new legislation. However, the issue may surface again when the Director-General of the Department of Environment, Climate Change and Water, issues new guidelines for national park visitor and tourist facilities. This will focus some attention on DECCW, the mega-department that so deftly swallowed up the National Parks and Wildlife Service several years ago.
Peter Prineas is a writer and lives in Sydney. His past roles include Chair of the Nature Conservation Council and member of the State Government’s National Parks and Wildlife Advisory Council.
NEW SOUTH WALES NATIONAL PARKS
- The next development opportunity
By Peter Prineas
[As published in the South Sydney Herald June 2010]
In May 2010 the NSW Environment Minister Frank Sartor tested the reaction of NSW environmental groups to a draft 'Sustainable Tourism' Bill that would alter the way the State’s national parks are managed. After a brief and not too friendly exchange in the media both sides went to ground.
The Bill follows a report presented by the Taskforce on Tourism and National Parks to former Premier Nathan Rees. The Taskforce is a tourism industry vehicle established in May 2008 when Matt Brown was tourism minister and Verity Firth held the environment portfolio. Rees released the report later that year and accepted the recommendations without inviting public comment.
The Taskforce did not bother with the detail of proposed changes to the National Parks and Wildlife Act. Its report said that key areas of the legislation should be 'clarified', giving the Government plenty of leeway in formulating amendments. The draft Bill is a cut and paste job that throws out much national parks philosophy and culture by allowing tourism to challenge the primacy of nature conservation in the Act.
Professor Ralph Buckley, Director of the International Centre for Ecotourism Research at Queensland’s Griffith University, has questioned the direction the NSW Government is taking. He told public meetings in Sydney that these changes in national parks management are coming from the top and that the senior managers are propagating a tourist industry myth that fewer people are visiting national parks. Contrary to the claims made by the NSW Department of Environment (DECCW), there is no need to ramp up tourism in national parks to meet the Government’s 2016 visitor target, as present trends indicate the target will easily be met.
The Government may be disappointed if it is looking for significant revenue from increased tourism development in national parks. Despite all the resorts at Kosciuszko National Park, the park is nowhere near self-funding. Intensive tourism in national parks is expensive to manage and commercial operators – with the possible exception of those leasing some heritage buildings such as lighthouses – do not meet all the costs they generate. Professor Buckley goes so far as to say that private development in national parks 'just does not work' and warns national parks agencies against giving away the profitable part of their business to private interests.
In South Africa, where national park tourism is a large industry, Professor Buckley says that 66% of national parks revenue comes from fees charged direct to visitors by the parks agency, with the commercial tourism operators contributing only 5%.
Among the various mantras to be heard in environmental circles in recent years, 'sustainable tourism' is one of the least convincing.
Millions of people visit NSW national parks each year and many facilities are provided for them. However, the Minister can’t lease or license land for uses that are outside the purposes of national parks laid down in the Act. Nor can he go outside certain allowed visitor uses and management principles. Attempts to approve inappropriate uses in parks have been struck down by the courts. One example is the business college the Greiner Government tried to establish in premises in the Sydney Harbour National Park. The college was evicted when its lease was challenged and ruled invalid.
Minister Sartor’s draft Bill aims to open up national parks to more development by inserting 'sustainable tourism' as a purpose of national parks and widening the uses for which leases and other concessions may be granted. Some may feel comfortable that tourism allowed under the Bill would be sustainable, but according to a senior barrister, Tim Robertson, the Bill does not define sustainable tourism and as it has no settled technical meaning, the courts will go to a dictionary and conclude that it gives national parks little protection. Robertson says it is no more than tourism managed in a way that “will not threaten or jeopardise future tourism”.
Among the various mantras to be heard in environmental circles in recent years, 'sustainable tourism' is one of the least convincing. We should have a tourist industry, but let’s not be deluded about the environmental consequences. Behind the window dressing is the real business of this draft Bill, which is to give national park developers greater opportunity, scope and certainty. This will ensure that national parks get more hotels, lodges, cabins and food outlets, all manner of retail shops, conference centres, recreational and sporting venues, educational facilities, research institutions, museums, galleries, cultural facilities, residential accommodation and various other kinds of developments mentioned in the Bill. Leases granting exclusive use rights to public buildings and to tracts of parkland are contemplated. Nature reserves at Port Macquarie and elsewhere are to be converted to national parks for the simple reason that nature reserves are not open to tourism developments. The Bill would even open up wilderness areas to commercial operations.
With a statutory duty to facilitate tourism and some important constraints removed, developments in national parks would proliferate and get bigger and proceed further down the path of privatisation. Visitors could be attracted to national parks for sporting events or just for the shopping. A unit in the National Parks head office has been working on this vision for some time.
Sartor’s Bill could do to tourism businesses in regional towns what shopping malls have done to Main Street.
Kosciuszko National Park offers a glimpse of the road ahead. There the resorts are evolving into towns and if you have the money you can spend half a million dollars buying an on-park villa or apartment. The Park’s real estate market might be limited to leasehold, but so is Canberra’s. The Kosciuszko resorts already accommodate ten thousand people overnight, and many more beds will be added when the Perisher Village and other developments are completed.
It is wishful thinking to imagine that all that tourism development can happen at Kosciuszko without harm to the environment. Despite the attempts of national park staff to manage the impacts, and the efforts of some operators, populations of endangered animals in the resort areas, such as the broad-toothed rat and the mountain pigmy possum, are in decline. This should matter, as much of the rationale for reserving land in national parks is to ensure that native species survive.
The backers of the new development at Perisher Valley might proceed with more confidence knowing that a full-blown shopping centre could be possible. But if this is to be future for national parks, then surrounding communities like Jindabyne that cater to park visitors might wonder about their future. Minister Sartor’s Bill could do to businesses in regional towns what shopping malls have done to Main Street. Communities all over NSW that rely on national park tourism – those in the Blue Mountains, towns around the Warrumbungles, settlements up and down the coast to mention a few – should be asking their members of parliament about this legislation.
As well as widening the scope for development in parks, the draft Bill would hand the Minister more discretion, making it harder for the community to rein in excesses through the courts. Reportedly the Minister responded to this criticism by suggesting that national parks would continue to be protected by their management plans. This is not very reassuring as the Minister ultimately decides what goes into national park management plans. If the Bill passes, his next step would be to change the plans to reflect the new legal regime and include in them that dodgy expression, sustainable tourism.