Saturday, April 6, 2013

Glamping and other unearthly delights, by Peter Prineas - tourism development in national parks

'Glamping and other unearthly delights'             

         By Peter Prineas

A talk on tourism development in national parks to the Blue Mountains Conservation Society,  Thursday 28 February 2013.


Concerns about tourism seem to pale into insignificance when we read newspaper reports of national parks in New South Wales being thrown open to 12-year-olds armed with high-powered rifles.

However tourism development can be more insidious and its effects more enduring. It does require our attention.

Although the NSW National Parks and Wildlife Act seems to be drifting away from the position that the national park system is primarily for nature conservation, it is a position that many people continue to hold.

A secondary purpose of the parks system is to provide for recreation compatible with nature conservation. Recreation can encompass many activities and at some point these activities merge into tourism, a concept which though it may be vague in outline, is readily understood as we have all been tourists at some time.


Tourism development is the issue, not visitors

I do not want to present the issue here as one of choosing between tourism in national parks, or nature conservation. It is really about tourism development in national parks. I want to argue for minimising development in national parks, not visitors.


Tourism developments in parks – do people want them?

In 2013 millions of people are visiting and enjoying NSW national parks and I don't believe there is any widespread demand or popular outcry for more tourism facilities to be built in our parks. The situation was much the same in 2010 when a bill favouring tourism developments in national parks was rushed through the NSW Parliament.

A Roy Morgan survey commissioned by Parks and Wildlife in 2008 found that NSW national parks received about 38 million domestic visits and 90% of visitors reported they were satisfied, and 57% very satisfied, with their experience.

A further survey in 2010 found that visits were lower at about 34.6 million but this was explained in the Morgan Survey as due to factors such as weather (extremely wet weather was experienced throughout 2010). Visitor satisfaction levels in 2010 were not significantly different to 2008.

In addition to the millions of domestic visits there were some further millions of international visits.

These survey results do not establish a serious decline in visitation to NSW national parks or that visitors are dissatisfied with their experiences.

In the USA a ‘gateway’ development policy has been in effect for many years. This policy favours locating, where possible, park visitor accommodation and other facilities in a gateway community on the national park approaches, rather than within the park. I recall that the National Parks Association began promoting this policy in NSW in the 1970s. I asked my US contacts if the policy on park developments had changed and was told that substantially it has not, although there remains a legacy of on-park developments in the older national parks.


Building and keeping a parks constituency

There are suggestions that park agencies globally are dealing with a decline in visitation and are anxious about losing their constituency. I do not think a case can be made for an overall global decline. Indeed national park visitation in East and Southeast Asia appears to be growing which is to be expected as millions of people are joining the middle class in that part of  the world.

If there were a general downward trend trend in visitation it would be a concern. However, building more tourism infrastructure in national parks is not the best or even an appropriate response. Other approaches may be effective and should be explored. These might include better promotion, or better linking of park visitation with off-park facilities and venues, or better transport, or providing a better experience or ‘product’ for the visitor (and I do not class as 'better' the sorts of facilities and experiences that can be provided outside national parks equally well and usually with less expense).


Is more tourism development the answer to declining park finances?

Declining finances are a threat to Australia's national parks. The states and the Commonwealth government are not adequately funding their parks systems and parks agencies are being forced to look to other sources of revenue. However, too often parks agencies derive little financial benefit from the commercial concessions in their parks.

Professor Ralph Buckley, Director of the International Centre for Ecotourism research at Griffith University, in addressing a public meeting in 2010, observed that national park concession holders – with the possible exception of those leasing some heritage buildings such as lighthouses – do not meet all the costs they generate. He went so far as to say that private development in national parks “just does not work” and warned against national parks agencies giving away the profitable part of their business to private interests.

Professor Buckley also observed that in South Africa, where national park tourism is a large industry, 66% of national parks revenue comes from fees charged direct to visitors by the parks agency, with the commercial tourism operators contributing only 5%.

The most developed national park in NSW is Kosciuszko National Park (KNP).  It accommodates the ski resorts. It has more beds than the town of Cooma. I have not seen any recent statement of KNP’s costs and revenues. However I think it is unlikely the situation would have changed much from the 1990s when I last saw some figures. It was a significant drain on Parks and Wildlife finances then and I have little doubt that it continues to be today. If the aim is to magnify park management costs then intensive tourism development seems to be the way to go. The cheapest management option is usually wilderness.

You can't develop a natural area without affecting natural conditions and the KNP resorts are a case in point. Among many impacts there has been a near loss of the Burramys (mountain pigmy possum) population on the Perisher Range and that of the broad-toothed marsupial rat at Smiggin Holes.

Up to 2011, I was a member of a committee responsible for the Perisher Range Resorts Environmental Management System. During the years I served on the committee I gained some insights into the problems the parks agency faces in protecting the environment. When the committee began work we found there was a lack of data. There was little monitoring. Ski lodges were using water without restraint. There was no metering. Some lodges ran their taps for 24 hours a day throughout the winter months to avoid freezing. There were problems with garbage disposal and the wastes were maintaining numbers of feral cats and foxes which preyed on the native wildlife. There were issues with pollution and contamination. These impacts have been reduced due to efforts of the committee to put in place an effective environmental management system, with the support of KNP staff and some of the lodges and commercial concession-holders. However much remains to be done.

It is impossible to discuss Kosciuszko National Park in this context without mentioning the unusual development culture that exists there, and which I hope we will not see in other national parks. At KNP, leasehold apartments and villas within the ski resort areas are developed and sold to private buyers. In other words there is a real estate market. The culmination of this culture can be seen in the government's attempts over some years to interest a private developer in building a ‘village’ on the Perisher Resort car park. The development received approval during Frank Sartor's time as Planning Minister. The 'village'  would cover an area equal to five football fields. There would be seven four-storey buildings with 239 apartments and associated retail, commercial and recreational facilities.

One hopes that other national parks do not follow the example of Kosciuszko in another respect: in KNP the parks agency ceased to be the consent authority for development within the park's resort areas some years ago; that role went over to the State’s planning agency.


Tourism developments in NSW National Parks given greater scope

The 2010 bill which brought in new arrangements for tourism developments in NSW national parks raised many concerns.

The rationale for the Bill appeared to be based on two myths. One of these myths was that visitor numbers for NSW national parks were in serious decline. 

Another myth was that the changes were needed to meet a target in the NSW State Plan which called for a 20% increase in visits to national parks by 2016. In fact the growth trend in visitation to NSW parks was sufficient to meet the 2016 target.

The 2008 O’Neil Report to the NSW Premier on the state of the tourism industry prepared the ground for the changes to the National Parks and Wildlife Act. It reported a decline in tourism in NSW, especially in regional areas. There was a decline in tourism, but the causes identified had little to do with national parks. In fact the report grossly understated national park visitation at 22 million. It then went on to attack the management of national parks and wilderness areas in NSW. The criticisms were based on ideology, not analysis; they were presented in general terms and mostly unsupported by examples or case studies. The Report argued for less regulation within the national park system.

After this "softening up" we saw the appointment of a Tourism Taskforce by the NSW Government. Senior people from community environmental organisations took part in this Taskforce and two organisations were funded by the state government to the amount of $20,000 each to prepare their submissions to the Taskforce. The cheques came with a covering letter from the Environment Minister, Verity Firth. The letter made particular reference to Tasmania's Bay of Fires resort and seemed to put it forward as an exemplar for NSW. I note that promotional material for this resort says "Bay of Fires lodge is the only building on 20 km of outstanding coastal wilderness". I expressed my view at the time that this funding should not have been accepted.

The Tourism Taskforce submitted a report recommending ‘clarification’ of a number of provisions of the National Parks and Wildlife Act. In effect it gave the government carte blanche to make changes.

Statements were emanating at this time from NSW Parks and Wildlife about "realigning our business" and making organisational changes to give greater emphasis to tourism development in parks.

The stage had been set some years before when the Australian Conservation Foundation and the IUCN signed up to a Tourism and Transport Forum (TTF) manifesto called 'National Parks and Tourism: A Natural Partnership'. The TTF is a high level tourism industry lobby. The TTF has worked its way around Australia's national parks agencies and has been able to move national parks policy to a stance that is now more accepting of development. Its success can be gauged by the reactions of NGOs in various states:


“Sartor's Tourism Bill Opens NSW National Parks for Business”    
- Nature  Conservation Council of NSW  June 2010 

“Private development push threatens Victoria's national parks”   
- Victorian National Parks Association August 2012


“Late last year, the State Government introduced changes to the
Nature Conservation Act that would provide 30 year leases for
ecotourism facilities, such as resorts, on National Park land.”         
- National Parks Association of Queensland February 2013


State and territory governments are being urged to compete with one another in opening up their national parks to tourism developments:

"Tasmania risks losing its grip on the wilderness tourism sector 
if it doesn’t make it easier to develop in national parks, says the 
Tourism Industry Council of Tasmania." 
- Hobart Mercury Aug 30, 2012


The 2010 legislative changes on tourism developments in NSW national parks

When the NSW National Parks and Wildlife Act was passed in 1967 the provisions concerned with visitor facilities consisted of just three sections amounting to about 500 words. By 2010 there were 20 sections with over 5000 words.

The 2010 changes removed or weakened constraints on developments in national parks imposed by a long a line of court decisions and widened the discretion of the Minister in granting national park concessions.

The bill introduced a range of uses for new developments in parks that had formerly been limited to existing buildings and structures. These uses included research facilities, conference and function centres, recreational, educational and cultural activities, sporting activities and retail shops. Also, existing buildings in parks which were formerly able to be adapted for a limited range of uses could now be put to ‘any use’.

Another change was to broaden the purposes for which developments could be provided from developments for ‘visitors’ to developments for ‘visitors or tourists’ The addition of ‘tourists’ might not seem important but it has the potential to facilitate developments in parks that are larger in scale and offer a more sophisticated and wider range of facilities than would be appropriate for a mere ‘visitor’.

A statutory duty to facilitate tourism in national parks was also introduced. This was achieved by amending the plan of management provisions so that park managers are obliged to identify sites for tourism developments when formulating plans.

If the aim of the 2010 amendments was to assure greater scope and certainty to proponents of tourism developments in national parks, they would seem to have achieved their purpose. However this will only be known when the provisions have been in operation for some time and have been tested in the courts.


Tourism in wilderness areas

The 2010 legislative changes also opened up wilderness areas to commercial operations. The NSW Wilderness Act was amended in order to effect this change.

The attention given to wilderness areas in the O'Neill Report and by the Tourism Taskforce was especially misdirected. It is wrong to think that wilderness areas do not contribute to tourism in NSW. Every year large numbers of tourists visit the Blue Mountains and go to the Echo Point Lookout at Katoomba and the Govetts Leap Lookout at Blackheath. The grand views that attract them to these places mainly consist of declared wilderness areas managed under the provisions of the NSW Wilderness Act and the National Parks and Wildlife Act. Most visitors are satisfied with these experiences in an accessible 'near wilderness' setting where services can be readily provided. There are many opportunities in NSW to provide such experiences, both within and outside national parks.

It is a mistake to think that commercial guided tours in wilderness areas will make no appreciable difference to the character or use of these areas. Wilderness tours involving small groups, carrying all their own requirements on their backs, and camping in the open, are not the agenda here. In order to operate tours at a commercial level, high fees will need to be charged and a level of service that may be incompatible with the Wilderness Act may need to be provided. Motor vehicle or helicopter support may be required. There may be pressure on operators and the parks agency to offer facilities and levels of comfort expected by the high value sector of the market, including structures for accommodation.

Wilderness management in the Oxley Wild Rivers National Park in the mid north coast hinterland is perhaps a case in point. The Green Gully property forming part of the wilderness area was purchased with the help of a public fund-raising campaign that raised over $170,000. It was the largest acquisition made by the Dunphy Wilderness Fund, established by former NSW Premier Bob Carr. However, before Green Gully could be brought under the Wilderness Act, the Parks agency renovated three rustic stockmen's huts by adding cooking facilities and sleeping quarters. New outdoor picnic tables, paved areas and fire places were built for paying visitors and intrusive signage was installed along a newly inaugurated “Green Gully Track”, contrary to wilderness management policy.

This development of tourism infrastructure within a wilderness area may be seen as a precedent. Will similar treatment be meted out to the Kosciuszko National Park wilderness areas and the high country stockmens' huts?


Glamping

Glamping is a term derived from the words glamour and camping.  

An Australian glamping provider explains the concept in this way:

Luxury Tented Five Star Accommodation Qld

Welcome to the worlds most romantic and luxurious fully self contained luxury tent accommodation. Our five star glamping tent is complete with every convenience you could never imagine you'd find whilst camping in a tent.

What is glamping you ask? Glamping is the most luxurious camping you will ever experience! It may be a tent and you might be camping, but with all its luxurious furnishings and fittings, we can easily call it a villa ... This is an 'Australian first' 5 star tent … experience the ultimate in luxury camping!

Glamping is better understood by looking at pictures of glamping situations. A selection of images can readily be found by searching Google Images using the term 'glamping'.

The purpose of glamping is to glamourise the camping experience to the point that it will support a high tariff and be profitable.

A glamping facility in Sydney's Lane Cove National Park advertises rates varying from $390 to $450 a day with continental breakfast and two bottles of wine thrown in. It is tucked away discretely in a corner of the park, off Plassey Road, North Ryde. Few park users would know it is there.

For glamping enterprises to really pay, they may need to migrate into the "dress circle" areas of the parks where friction with non-glampers might be expected.


 National parks – a democratic institution

In closing I will mention the importance of national parks as a democratic institution. The parks are public lands and open to everyone. They are made accessible by roads, walking tracks, signage and camping areas and visitors are free to engage in recreation that is compatible with nature conservation and which does not interfere with the enjoyment of others.

Regrettably, democracy in the parks may be under threat due to legislative and policy changes that could see desirable sites appropriated for the enjoyment of those willing and able to pay.